A close cropped photo of the word "Justice" etched into the marble facade of a building.

 Carlson v. BNSF Railway Company

Halunen Law increased its winning appellate record for 2019 to 3-0, with the recent Carlson v. BNSF Railway Company decision. Partner Christopher Moreland was specially retained to litigate the appeal in this case and the win is particularly notable—the Court of Appeals reinstated a $207,333 jury award that a District Court had taken away.

On November 11, 2015, Jason Carlson was working as a conductor for the BNSF railroad when his employer assigned him to take a train from Minneapolis to Dilworth. What BNSF knew, but Carlson did not, is that the locomotive on his train was unsafe. Indeed, before assigning Carlson and his engineer to use that particular locomotive, the BNSF received reports from the previous operating crew that the toilet in its cab was leaking chemicals and human waste, thus dispersing noxious fumes throughout cab. When he boarded the locomotive and smelled the stench, Carslon again reported the engine as defective, but his bosses ignored him and sent the train on its way.

Throughout the trip, Carlson inhaled the dangerous fumes and, not surprisingly, became sick. Unfortunately, his illness proved to be long-lasting, and his doctors ultimately diagnosed him with irritant induced asthma and vocal cord dysfunction as a result of his exposure. Although Carlson was able to return to his conductor’s duties following the incident, his respiratory system had been permanently compromised, and he was forced to work a less demanding schedule, which, in turn, caused him to earn less money.

Carlson sued the BNSF in Hennepin County (Minnesota) District Court, and on October 9, 2017, the jury returned a verdict in his favor, concluding that BNSF was at fault for assigning Carlson to work on an unsafe locomotive and awarding Carlson damages, including $207,333.00 to compensate him for his loss of earning capacity (i.e., his reduced ability to earn due to his injuries). Once the trial was over, however, the BNSF filed a motion arguing that the evidence Carlson had presented at trial was not sufficient to support the jury’s verdict. The trial judge granted the BNSF’s motion and took away the $207,333 award for his loss of earning capacity.

Halunen Law to Challenge

After receiving the judge’s order, Carlson’s trial counsel hired Halunen Law to challenge it in the Minnesota Court of Appeals. On February 26, 2019, Halunen Law attorney Chris Moreland appeared before the court, arguing that the trial judge had invaded the province of the jury and wrongly took away its verdict.[1] On May 20, 2019, the Minnesota Court of Appeals issued its opinion reversing the trial judge’s order and reinstated the jury’s award in favor of Carlson.[2]

Said Moreland, “the right to a jury trial is guaranteed by the Constitution, and it is the bedrock upon which our justice system is founded. In this case, the jury spoke. My client suffered serious injuries, and the jury awarded him damages. I’m happy I could help make sure Mr. Carlson will now receive the compensation the jury determined he deserves.”
[1] A recording of the oral argument 

A closely cropped illustration of the Minnesota flag focusing on the Minnesota seal in blue, red, and yellow.

A Victory to Minnesota Employees

The Minnesota Supreme Court has just handed a victory to Minnesota employees who have been disabled as a result of a workplace injury. The Court’s recent ruling in the Daniel v. City of Minneapolis case, states that employees who develop a disabling condition resulting from an on-the-job injury may now recover workers’ compensation benefits for that injury, and they may bring a separate claim for disability discrimination under the Minnesota Human Rights Act. This case overturns a 1989 Minnesota Supreme Court case, Karst v. F.C. Hayer Co., which held that the sole recourse for employees with disabilities resulting from an on-the-job injury was to receive workers’ compensation benefits. For three decades the Karst ruling has prevented employees with disabilities from a workplace injury from pursuing their rights under the Minnesota Human Rights Act. As a result of the Daniel decision, Karst has been overruled, and disabled employees across the state may now pursue all of the remedies they are entitled to under the law.

Minnesota Lawyer:

Read recent article in the Minnesota Lawyer about this case:

Court rules for firefighter in disability case

Star Tribune:

Read a recent article in the Star-tribune about this case:

Former Minneapolis firefighter will be able to sue for disability discrimination, high court rules

A rectangular logo with black letters reading "halunen law" accompanied by the tagline "Employment, Consumer, Whistleblower".Halunen Law, Lockridge Grindal Nauen P.L.L.P., and Levin Sedran & Berman, announced recently that plaintiffs they represented entered into an agreement to settle various class actions relating to IKO roofing shingles. The settlement applies to the “organic” asphalt shingles that were installed on buildings in the United States primarily between 1978 and 2008.

Read the recent press release about this settlement
(https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/iko-settles-class-action-lawsuit-regarding-organic-asphalt-shingles-300742840.html)

People who own or owned buildings with IKO organic shingles can obtain additional information about the settlement by checking the website at http://www.ikoorganicroofingshinglesclassactionsettlement.com

whistleblower

What is a Whistleblower?

Has your treatment on the job changed recently? Have you suddenly received performance criticisms you have never received before? Were you terminated for a bogus reason? And did this negative treatment come after a time you told your employer or a government agency that the company was doing something illegal?

If this sounds familiar, you may be a whistleblower and the workplace retaliation you have experienced is likely illegal. Many states (including Minnesota) and federal statutes prohibit what has happened to you and you may have recourse for the damage caused by the retaliation.

Read More…

Number One: Basics about Gender Discrimination

Halunen Law - Number One: Basics about Gender Discrimination Employment in Minnesota is at-will, unless you are in a union or have an employment contract. What this means is that your employer can terminate you at any time, for any reason, even if that reason is unfair or untrue.

However, your employer cannot terminate you for an illegal reason. Examples of illegal reasons to terminate a woman include: because she is a woman, or because she gets pregnant or has children to care for. Of course, employers will hardly ever come out and say that this is the reason they’re terminating someone. But it can often be deduced from all of the circumstances that the true reason for the termination is an illegal one. For example, a woman who has a strong performance history at her job tells her boss she’s pregnant. Suddenly, her boss, who previously only had praise for her work, becomes hyper-critical, and starts writing her up for small, vague, or non-existent “performance problems,” and then terminates her within weeks of her disclosing her pregnancy. This is considered evidence of pregnancy discrimination, and could potentially form the basis for a lawsuit. If you believe you are being discriminated against at work because of your sex, pregnancy, or another illegal reason, it’s best to report that discrimination to a supervisor or Human Resources employee, in writing, to document your concerns. If that doesn’t resolve your situation, consulting with an attorney can provide additional options.

Read More…

SAINT PAUL, Minn. (December 1, 2017) — A dermatologist’s whistleblower lawsuit recovered $850,000 for his fellow taxpayers, as the U.S. government settled fraud claims against a Minnesota skin-care practice and its owner, whom it had accused of false billing and unnecessary surgical procedures.

The Employment Law Group® law firm represented the whistleblower, Dr. Jeff Samuelson, with the assistance of local attorney Susan Coler of Halunen Law.

In his lawsuit, Dr. Samuelson alleged that Michael J. Ebertz, a dermatologist and owner of Skin Care Doctors, P.A. (SCD), based in Burnsville, Minn., profited by knowingly treating many patients’ benign skin lesions as if they were pre-cancerous — and then billing Medicare, the government insurance program, for procedures that weren’t medically necessary and shouldn’t have been reimbursed by taxpayers.

According to Dr. Samuelson’s complaint, Dr. Ebertz also used other methods to profit illegally from his patients’ visits — and urged other doctors in the practice to follow his lead, which they refused to do. Dr. Ebertz’s patients were unaware of the manipulation, according to Dr. Samuelson, who was a partowner of SCD at the time but was forced out after uncovering the scheme.

Dr. Samuelson now practices dermatology in California.

After investigating Dr. Samuelson’s claims, the U.S. government largely echoed his accusations and negotiated a settlement in which Dr. Ebertz denied wrongdoing yet agreed to pay $850,000 on his own behalf and for SCD. He also agreed to pay Dr. Samuelson’s attorney fees, and to stop billing Medicare for the disputed practices.

“This settlement is an important statement about the proper conduct of medicine,” said David L. Scher of The Employment Law Group, who was Dr. Samuelson’s lead attorney in the case. “When people visit a clinic such as SCD, they must be treated based on sound medical judgment — not based on how much money they can generate for a doctor’s bank account.”

The United States was represented in the case by Assistant U.S. Attorney Ann M. Bildtsen and members of the Office for the U.S. Attorney for the District of Minnesota. Dr. Samuelson brought the lawsuit under the federal False Claims Act (FCA) and will receive a reward of $153,000 for his whistleblowing.

The FCA, originally signed into law by President Abraham Lincoln in 1863, makes it illegal to deceive the federal government for financial gain. In addition to steep penalties for violators, it includes a “qui tam” provision that allows whistleblowers to file a legal complaint on behalf of taxpayers and — if they prevail — to receive a share of the proceeds.

“Jeff took a tough stand against his boss, and was pushed out of the SCD practice as a result,” said R. Scott Oswald, managing principal of The Employment Law Group. “He could have kept quiet and moved on, but instead he stood up for taxpayers and future SCD patients, achieving a measure of justice with the strongest whistleblower tool available for Medicare fraud — the False Claims Act. He’s a model of medical ethics and a beacon for doctors and other medical professionals who witness wrongdoing by their colleagues.”

“Along with Jeff and local counsel Susan Coler, we’re grateful to AUSA Bildtsen and her aggressive team in Minneapolis, and to Acting U.S. Attorney Gregory G. Brooker,” noted Mr. Scher. “They recognized the harm to Minnesota citizens, as well as to federal coffers, and they moved smartly to hold Dr. Ebertz to account.”

David Scher, a principal of The Employment Law Group, and Susan Coler, a partner in Halunen Law, are available for interviews about this case. Dr. Samuelson’s original complaint in the case, filed in 2015, is available here.

—————–

About The Employment Law Group
The Employment Law Group® law firm represents employees who stand up to wrongdoing in the workplace. Based in Washington, D.C., the firm takes cases nationwide. More information about The Employment Law Group and its attorneys is available at https://www.EmploymentLawGroup.com.

About Halunen Law

Based in Minneapolis, Minn., Halunen Law represents employees, consumers, and whistleblowers in actions against corporations that have committed wrongdoing. More information about Halunen Law and its attorneys is available at https://www.halunenlaw.com.

Clay Halunen

The founder of Halunen Law, Clayton Halunen spent more than 25 years as a trial lawyer seeking justice for employees, from delivery drivers to CEOs, in individual, class action, and whistleblower cases. Raised in northern Minnesota by parents who both experienced workplace discrimination, he built his career holding powerful companies accountable for illegal conduct, including some of the largest corporations in the country. His work includes a $1.5 billion settlement in a pharmaceutical fraud False Claims Act whistleblower lawsuit. Learn more about Clayton Halunen.

An up-close portrait of a smiling woman with short brown hair

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Rochester Police Officer Who Opposed Racial Bias and Excessive Force
Obtains $1 Million Settlement, Halunen Law Reports.

MINNEAPOLIS – (Sept. 19, 2017) A Rochester, Minn. police officer has obtained a $1 million settlement from the city of Rochester to resolve her employment discrimination and retaliation claims against the Rochester Police Department, according to Minneapolis-based Halunen Law, the firm representing the officer.

In 2016, Rochester Police Lt. Elisa Umpierre reported suspected racial bias in a decision to deny a favorable assignment to another police officer. Later that year, Rochester Police Chief Roger Peterson filed an internal complaint against Umpierre, allegedly based on Facebook posts Umpierre had published.
Read More…

The whistleblower case filed on behalf of Paul Olson, a high level employee of Minnesota’s Department of Human Services (DHS) has settled for $295,000. Olson had alleged that the DHS had ostracized him and removed all meaningful responsibilities from his position after he refused his managers’ demands to violate a statute to give a financial benefit to Fairview University Medical Center. The terms of the settlement include compensation for wage damages and  emotional distress. View the Olson v. DHS Settlement Agreement.

Click link to view video: Whistleblowers Help Curb Corporate Fraud

Screen Shot 2013-09-11 at 9.38.33 AM

The Minnesota Court of Appeals recently handed down a victory for employees in Sletten v. Crop Production Services. The Court of Appeals ruled that an employer could be liable for damages when it made false promises to an employee that caused him to turn down a more lucrative job offer. Halunen attorneys represented the employee, Brian Sletten.

Mr. Sletten was working as a manager for Crop Production Services (“CPS”) when another company offered him a higher-paying position. Mr. Sletten enjoyed his job and liked his co-workers at CPS. He told CPS he was considering the higher-paying job offer.

Read More…

© 2026 Halunen Law | Minneapolis Employment Attorneys