The public-private partnership envisioned by the qui tam provisions of the False Claims Act (FCA) is one of its most successful and powerful aspects, yielding billions of dollars in recoveries. The FCA permits the Government, the whistleblower, and their attorneys to cooperate—and they often do—when investigating and litigating FCA claims. But are there limits to that cooperation? Can government officials ask a whistleblower to secretly record conversations between the whistleblower and individuals who are under investigation but are represented by an attorney? The answer, according to one federal court, is “yes.”
Employer Fraud
One of the first and most frequent arguments defendants make in fighting qui tam allegations under the False Claims Act (FCA) is that the case brought by the whistleblower, or “relator,” is not viable because it is based on publicly available information, the relator is not an “original source” of that information, or both. On February 19, 2020, the First Circuit Court of Appeals issued an important decision clarifying that to qualify as an original source, a relator need not have participated in the fraud or observed it in operation. Instead, a relator may qualify as an original source if the relator sees or receives information that is suggestive of fraud, hears suspicious conversations, and discovers additional evidence of fraud through personal investigation. United States ex rel. Banigan v. PharMerica, Inc., No. 18-1487, 2020 WL 813258, at *8-9 (1st Cir. Feb. 19, 2020).
Beginning in 2005, Allegiance entered into agreements with hospitals located in the Southeastern United States to provide Intensive Outpatient Psychotherapy services to patients who were Medicare beneficiaries on the hospitals’ behalf. The settlement resolves allegations that many patients were provided services that did not qualify for Medicare reimbursement but were billed as such.
SAINT PAUL, Minn. (December 1, 2017) — A dermatologist’s whistleblower lawsuit recovered $850,000 for his fellow taxpayers, as the U.S. government settled fraud claims against a Minnesota skin-care practice and its owner, whom it had accused of false billing and unnecessary surgical procedures.
The Employment Law Group® law firm represented the whistleblower, Dr. Jeff Samuelson, with the assistance of local attorney Susan Coler of Halunen Law.
In his lawsuit, Dr. Samuelson alleged that Michael J. Ebertz, a dermatologist and owner of Skin Care Doctors, P.A. (SCD), based in Burnsville, Minn., profited by knowingly treating many patients’ benign skin lesions as if they were pre-cancerous — and then billing Medicare, the government insurance program, for procedures that weren’t medically necessary and shouldn’t have been reimbursed by taxpayers.
According to Dr. Samuelson’s complaint, Dr. Ebertz also used other methods to profit illegally from his patients’ visits — and urged other doctors in the practice to follow his lead, which they refused to do. Dr. Ebertz’s patients were unaware of the manipulation, according to Dr. Samuelson, who was a partowner of SCD at the time but was forced out after uncovering the scheme.
Dr. Samuelson now practices dermatology in California.
After investigating Dr. Samuelson’s claims, the U.S. government largely echoed his accusations and negotiated a settlement in which Dr. Ebertz denied wrongdoing yet agreed to pay $850,000 on his own behalf and for SCD. He also agreed to pay Dr. Samuelson’s attorney fees, and to stop billing Medicare for the disputed practices.
“This settlement is an important statement about the proper conduct of medicine,” said David L. Scher of The Employment Law Group, who was Dr. Samuelson’s lead attorney in the case. “When people visit a clinic such as SCD, they must be treated based on sound medical judgment — not based on how much money they can generate for a doctor’s bank account.”
The United States was represented in the case by Assistant U.S. Attorney Ann M. Bildtsen and members of the Office for the U.S. Attorney for the District of Minnesota. Dr. Samuelson brought the lawsuit under the federal False Claims Act (FCA) and will receive a reward of $153,000 for his whistleblowing.
The FCA, originally signed into law by President Abraham Lincoln in 1863, makes it illegal to deceive the federal government for financial gain. In addition to steep penalties for violators, it includes a “qui tam” provision that allows whistleblowers to file a legal complaint on behalf of taxpayers and — if they prevail — to receive a share of the proceeds.
“Jeff took a tough stand against his boss, and was pushed out of the SCD practice as a result,” said R. Scott Oswald, managing principal of The Employment Law Group. “He could have kept quiet and moved on, but instead he stood up for taxpayers and future SCD patients, achieving a measure of justice with the strongest whistleblower tool available for Medicare fraud — the False Claims Act. He’s a model of medical ethics and a beacon for doctors and other medical professionals who witness wrongdoing by their colleagues.”
“Along with Jeff and local counsel Susan Coler, we’re grateful to AUSA Bildtsen and her aggressive team in Minneapolis, and to Acting U.S. Attorney Gregory G. Brooker,” noted Mr. Scher. “They recognized the harm to Minnesota citizens, as well as to federal coffers, and they moved smartly to hold Dr. Ebertz to account.”
David Scher, a principal of The Employment Law Group, and Susan Coler, a partner in Halunen Law, are available for interviews about this case. Dr. Samuelson’s original complaint in the case, filed in 2015, is available here.
—————–
About The Employment Law Group
The Employment Law Group® law firm represents employees who stand up to wrongdoing in the workplace. Based in Washington, D.C., the firm takes cases nationwide. More information about The Employment Law Group and its attorneys is available at https://www.EmploymentLawGroup.com.
About Halunen Law
Based in Minneapolis, Minn., Halunen Law represents employees, consumers, and whistleblowers in actions against corporations that have committed wrongdoing. More information about Halunen Law and its attorneys is available at https://www.halunenlaw.com.

The founder of Halunen Law, Clayton Halunen spent more than 25 years as a trial lawyer seeking justice for employees, from delivery drivers to CEOs, in individual, class action, and whistleblower cases. Raised in northern Minnesota by parents who both experienced workplace discrimination, he built his career holding powerful companies accountable for illegal conduct, including some of the largest corporations in the country. His work includes a $1.5 billion settlement in a pharmaceutical fraud False Claims Act whistleblower lawsuit. Learn more about Clayton Halunen.

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Rochester Police Officer Who Opposed Racial Bias and Excessive Force
Obtains $1 Million Settlement, Halunen Law Reports.
MINNEAPOLIS – (Sept. 19, 2017) A Rochester, Minn. police officer has obtained a $1 million settlement from the city of Rochester to resolve her employment discrimination and retaliation claims against the Rochester Police Department, according to Minneapolis-based Halunen Law, the firm representing the officer.
In 2016, Rochester Police Lt. Elisa Umpierre reported suspected racial bias in a decision to deny a favorable assignment to another police officer. Later that year, Rochester Police Chief Roger Peterson filed an internal complaint against Umpierre, allegedly based on Facebook posts Umpierre had published.
Read More…
I get calls several times a week from executives and professionals who want me to review a severance agreement that was just presented to them by their employer. When I ask if they think they have any potential claims against the company, people seem bewildered. I’m often told they just want me to review the severance—that they don’t want to risk losing what is offered, and have no interest in seeing if they could get more. I, on the other hand, am often dumbfounded. After all, negotiation is part of business—right? As an executive or professional part of your job typically includes some form of negotiation. So then, why would you not negotiate over a severance?
Honesty is the best policy. It’s one of the first lessons we learn, and yet it seems there is an epidemic of selective memory loss among providers who choose to defraud Medicare. Our journey begins in South Carolina where another medical provider is paying out millions in an effort to put the allegations of wrongdoing behind them.
This past summer, the Justice Department announced that Lexington County Health Services District Inc. d/b/a Lexington Medical Center located in West Columbia, South Carolina, had agreed to a $17 Million settlement. (1) The settlement resolved allegations that the Center had maintained improper financial relationships with physicians they employed and submitted fraudulent claims to Medicare. This is extremely troubling considering a large percentage of their income is from Government funded programs.
People who rely on Medicare are among our nation’s most vulnerable citizens, including the elderly, disabled and terminally ill. In many cases, this is truly their only hope for receiving the medical care they so desperately need, but many could not otherwise afford. Subsequently an extensive body of law protects the rights of these recipients and safeguards the tax payer dollars funding these services with severe penalties for those who choose to ignore them.

Hospice and greed. Two words that are diametrically opposed and when combined—toxic.
At its inception, hospice in America was mostly a philanthropic movement led by volunteers and non-profit entities. Today the hospice industry is big business including a large percentage of for-profit providers. According to the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MEDPAC) in 2013 Medicare hospice expenditures alone totaled about $15.1 billion for services rendered by over 3,900 providers. (1)
The hospice movement is built on the core belief that patient dignity and respect are fundamental to providing compassionate care to the dying. When the prognosis of a terminal illness carries a life expectancy of 6 months or less it’s devastating. Hospice includes access to essential medical care along with emotional and psychological support which enables individuals and their loved ones to live as fully as possible in the time remaining while striving to come to terms with saying good-bye.

The diagnosis: Cancer. Few words have the power to alter one’s life as dramatically as those six letters linked with the phrase – “test results.” The Journey begins. The two critical elements for any cancer patient are affordable care and a physician that, above else, you can trust with your life. There is an ethical expectation that providers will live up to their oath to make the patient’s need their top priority, abstain from medical malfeasance and recognize and be mindful of the impact their patients’ care can have on the stability of their families and finances.(1)
Tuesday, March 8, 2016, a press release by the Department of Justice (2) announced a $37-million-dollar settlement with 21st Century Oncology Inc., the nation’s largest physician led integrated cancer care provider, and its wholly owned subsidiary South Florida Radiation Oncology LLC. The False Claims Act lawsuit included allegations that they defrauded Medicare and other federal health care programs including TRICARE, the Department of Defense military health program supporting our uniformed services.

The Star Tribune published an article today about how a mental health agency, Complementary Support Services, that was supposed to provide quality services to a vulnerable population, instead is reported to have engaged in rampant fraud that “bilked the state’s Medicaid program of millions of dollars and provided inadequate supervision of unlicensed practitioners.” That private agency is now the subject of a federal and state False Claims Act qui tam lawsuit that resulted from a report to the government by a former employee.
The False Claims Act is designed to encourage citizens to challenge conduct that cheats private agency clients and wrongfully takes taxpayers money to do so. It also provides whistleblower protection to employees who are treated badly or fired because they challenge, report or refuse to engage in illegal conduct. The goal of the law is to stop fraud in its tracks by encouraging oversight by employees, recipients of services and the public.